Manmohan(mania)

Manmohan Singh got installed as Prime Minister of India in 2004. Most of the intellectuals sighed relief. They were perhaps not prepared to see a country with Sonia as Prime Minister. Many including myself thought the model of putting the technically best person might be a better route with deteriorating images of politicians. I wrote too. But has not the experiment failed?
For some time now I have writing and expecting that a technocrat like Manmohan must take a plea such as deteriorating health and leave. With passing days many are expressing doubts about his effectiveness. Recently I saw few interesting views from some.

Shobha De wants Manmohan to take a lesson from Bauji of ‘Paliala House’. I went to watch the movie after reading the column.

Manmohan Singh has to realize this mess is not about just him —it isn’t enough to claim individual moral superiority and go about with his own conduct above suspicion. It is about closing his eyes, looking the other way and keeping mum. He says he has a job to do (darling, please do it!) and he’s not quitting. Fine. Don’t quit, Sir. But could you please get on with it? That dreaded and disgusting ‘C-word’ (compromise ) has been used excessively by the PM. Someone should have told him it’s a lousy excuse to trot out at a time the country needs to hear something better. He spoke about his personal frustration. But what about the collective frustration of the one billion plus citizens of India ? And excuse me, but it sounds bloody awful when a leader confesses he is not ‘as big a culprit’ as he’s made out to be. Reading into that line, it would be fair to conclude we can call him a chhota-mota culprit… not a big one!


From Times of India

Ashok V. Desai wrote a good piece ‘CAESAR’S WIFE’S HUSBAND’ in The Telegraph, Kolkata.

Bit the nest one was one I read in Delhi Times by Diksha Kamra, ‘GUMSUM NA RAHO, PM JI’. I would love to hear Palash Sen’s song Aa Dekhoon Main Kya Hai Masla,Naa Jaanu Main Sach Hai Kya,Tha Jo Tere Mann Mein Bhool Ja,Par Gumsum Raho Naarequesting the prime minister not to show up everywhere with a sad expression!

I would have loved to read or hear Shail Chaturvedi or Surendra Sharma, if they have some new on Manmohan.

I don’t think, Manmohan is going to comply anyone.

Posted in economy, governance | Tagged | Leave a comment

Budget – An Appeal to Pranab Babu and an Anguish

For last so many years I have been watching this exercise of the government. Over the years, the majority in salaried class looks at it with a great hope. But every time it comes with some drops in the empty ocean of expectations. Inflation gets higher than the rise in annual increments and the households are to resort to cutting even essential expenditure. For a change why should you not come out with some real down to earth announcements this time for the salaried class?

1. Instead of raising the tax exemption every time by thousands, please for a change raise the bar to Rs 6, 00,000 per year. Look at the inflation in usual expenses at least in two areas of necessity:

• School fee in all good private schools have gone sky high. Could you think of spending Rs 2 lakh annually for your son in high school?

• Medical costs are equally getting exorbitant. How can a salaried person give Rs 12 lakh for hospitalization for 12 days in a hospital? Don’t you know that many are to decide to die rather than telling the family head about the trouble?

Alternatively, please make all payments for education in schools and actual expenses for the hospital and medicines deductable from taxable income.

For all retired persons above 70 years who had contributed in income tax kitty, particularly those from private sector with no pension, can the government make at least the medical expenses in all hospital free?

And finally I have an appeal for the benefit of millions of migrant workers. Can you get Money Order up to Rs 2000 free? Further, is it an inclusive government that charges 5%, that is, Rs 100 for sending Es 2000? It’s a big money for those who send money by MO

Why can’t your tech-savvy minister get implement fast the digital transfer of MO money through cellular phone? Interestingly, most of the senders, payees as well as the postmen even in the remotest rural region are having the gadgets. Perhaps you may not know, even today in 2011, a money order sometimes take a month or more to reach from New Delhi to a village in Bihar.

I have heard the President’s speech of promises and wishes with concerns for the people of India. Does the government really work for the intended beneficiaries or the intermediaries and those benefiting from millions of government tenders?

PS: Pranab Babu! Your government will come with many freebies in 2013 budget before general election. Many think you should do that now to divert the damage caused by various recent scams.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Manmohan, Media and Opposition

I watched the whole of Manmohan’s press interactions today. He kept on emphasizing that he is not a lame duck prime minister. Manmohan Singh vowed to stay in office to press ahead with reforms. I shall wish the people to judge by two promises he made.

Let us wait till the end of the budget session after which he promised to have a major cabinet reshuffle. Will he able to touch any of the strong weight poor performer or unscrupulous minister? Will he be giving some challenging ministries to the young brigade already in ministry and are subordinating the heavy weights?

Manmohan has also promised that no wrongdoers would be spared. He didn’t provide a time-frame. He must not keep the people of India waiting for long. Can he not bring the wealth siphoned back in nation’s exchequer through an ordinance with a clause of paying back with interest if the courts acquit the wrongdoers?

However, I am shocked that none of the editors present there asked questions on the performances of his ministers. How many kms of roads were built against a promise of 20 km per day? Why are we failing to provide power to the country men even after so many years? What is the reduction in the number of cases in the courts? How long will it take to his Bharat Nirman targets that were to be finished by 2009? What time will it take to execute at least some of the projects in Orissa, Chattisgarh, and Jharkhand? What is the progress on the Sibal’s dream plans of skilling and educating India?

Why the editors were so meek with no concern on the speed of development and reform? Many questions would have come from the elite journalists of the small screen.

And then why is the major opposition party also failing badly to take up these development issues, be it of physical infrastructure or HDI, where the government keeps on promising with no significant improvements? It never came out even with a strong denial of the prime minister’s charge on it for blackmailing?

Many perceive to day that Manmohan’s aura is fast fading.
—-
PS: Views of Suhel Seth: “The press conference held last week by Manmohan Singh, India’s prime minister, was an unmitigated disaster. Mr Singh’s enormous brand was felled at the hands of some very reasonable television folks. None of them was out for the kill. But then the prey succumbed even without any poisoned arrows being fired.”

Posted in economy | Leave a comment

A letter to Sonia Gandhi

I saw Chetan Bhagat’s letter to Sonia Gandhi and if that reaches Sonia Gandhi I will like to add some more point to the letter.

Can she take an initiative to see that Congress members in every constituency start working for social causes such as education, healthcare, employment generation as Mahatma Gandhi taught the party through various movements and initiatives such as Khadi, Harijan, sanitation or Salt making?

Let the political parties compete with its work done for the community instead of muscle or money power. Corruption can end only if the candidates are selected for the work done for the community and the community selects them for the services they delivered,

The end of present basis of selection through some brave initiatives can only bring the end of the greedy lot who are entering politics only to make money and live a standard of life of top business men and wealthy people.

The national party must encourage the people who work and serve at the grassroots level.

Further I couldn’t agree to the concept of stipend for younger interns in politics as suggested by Bhagat. What will be the amount? Will that satisfy the present generation’s aspiration? How long can the stipend work?

I shall like Sonia to judge her leaders by performance. Inefficiency and ineffectiveness must be punished and not accommodated. And the report in media must be honoured after verification and a criminal must be eliminated from the party without waiting for his conviction. For example, persons such as ND Tiwari’s case and those involved in Radia’s tape case.

I shall further appeal to Sonia to dissuade Rahul from inviting young students from universities to politics. Let them focus on academic activities. There has already been a lot of erosion in academic areas. Let the party encourage people from many streams with working experiences in different sectors.

As a last but not the least important point in appeal I shall like Sonia to consider a question in many minds. Should you not consider a change of the person in the highest chair? Let Pranab or someone else be tried. May be that the people may feel happy with a changed face. Madam! A lot of water has gone down Ganga since you renounced the prime minister’s post. Either Rahul or you yourself can occupy the chair of the prime minister. There is nothing to worry. This country accepts every one without bias. Let it not be too late for the people.

Posted in economy, indian politics | Tagged | Leave a comment

Why doesn’t Manmohan Resign or Retire

With all types of scams appearing almost daily, any self respecting prime minister would have resigned, After all as a prime minster of the country, he owns the responsibility. If one of his cabinet ministers has been corrupt, the prime minister must also own a part of responsibility for not keeping a watch on the system that makes it happen.

Why doesn’t the prime minister resign? Does he think that there is no one in the country or Congress who can replace him and run the government? Is Manmohan having an inferiority complex because of being the elected prime minister or one planted by Sonia? Why would he compare himself with other prime minister and talk of his holding the chair for record number of years or twice in succession?

After all Manmohan, as claimed, is a top class economist respected even by Obama, why should he be afraid of resigning from the job? Even if he needs engagement after the retirement he can be on the consulting panels of many corporate or global bodies or he can earn as Clinton does by speaking at different platforms.

The country expected him to be actively contributing to toning up the government and the administration for better efficiency. Why couldn’t he bring about any significant changes and reform? Why is he content with living in the glory of his tenure as finance minister of Narsingha Rao? Why could not he bring about the changes in labour laws for improving manufacturing that can provide the employment? If he claims to get through the nuclear bill why could he take a similar stand on the reforms that could really help in solving many problems of fast growth?

If Manmohan Singh could oversee Railways during Lalu why did he allow Railway to become a white elephant during Mamtaa regime? Why couldn’t even a single railway station be transformed to world class standard of conveniences?

Is he not responsible for India failing to become number one in steel and textile production? Why India should exports cotton and iron ores and not the finished product? Is not a shame that India produce only around 70 million ton of steel and takes pride in that? Why are so many of the industrial houses waiting for all these years to get the construction of steel plants started? Why the project delay cost are in hundreds of thousands crores?

Why should Manmohan not allocate coal linkages for the power plants in Bihar or not allow sugar industries to come up in the state in big way that could bring prosperity in the poor state?

Every day one can read stories after stories somehow linked with PM’s failure, be it the Coal India’s mismanagement or PMO inefficiency in ISRO or 2G?

Why should Manmohan and his minster after six years of their rule keep on blaming NDA for all the ills?

Finally how can a minister failing to expedite the road building do what is required to build the shabby Indian cities to global standards? Is it not a shame that a former, president of CII and the vice chairman of an automobile company complains of not having proper road to get in the supplies and transport the finished vehicles out of plant in Rudrapur in so many years? Can one think of a super power taking more time to transport a container truck from Mumbai to Gurgaon that to bring that in from Singapore to Mumbai in ship?

Why should a rikshawala of Bihar pay Rs 100 to post office for sending Rs 2000 to his village home in Bihar and that also taking 20 days?

Can Manmohan Singh convince that six years of rules are not good enough to change these?

I am sure as an old man Manmohan must be wishing to retire and resign but Sonia may not be allowing him to do that. Rahul is hesitant and others are afraid.

Posted in governance, indian politics | Tagged | Leave a comment

Anti-people Business Houses

It appears over the years the short term gains and profit orientation have so much gotten into the mindset of the business community, particularly the those at top of the pack that it hardly bother about the wretched condition of the millions of people of the community whom they exploit and in which they exist and grow.

For me there is only one priority and that is a goal of having 100% educated Indians. I can bet ‘attain it and India becomes superpower’. I feel bad as the business houses are not doing anything significant in that direction leaving the majority of the responsibility to the government. The business houses today even don’t bother to educate its own employees and still expect them to contribute the best through major innovation. How many of the business houses, the bug ones, are having a system of continuous education of all of its employees? Why can’t it bear the social responsibility of the education of all the children of the employees? Will it significantly upset its budget? If these business houses take it as a mission, it is easy to do, but if it does it for meeting certain mandatory requirement, it will never happen.

I shall like to talk of only few concrete sectors. Every one today knows about the telecom sector because of its unique expansion. And all these companies are making money and also are behind billion worth of scams. Should the companies not encourage the young boys and girls engaged in the sector for higher education and skill and spend on it? If the Japanese in good old days could make the nation learn the significance of quality and quality circle through radio programmes, why can’t the telecom operators educate the 700 million people with handsets?

The country today produces about 2 million of automobiles that need skill of using as well as in maintaining of the machines. Can someone tell me the capacity of the schools or facilities for training drivers and motor mechanics in the country? Can’t the business houses take this responsibility? Why should they expect that also as government job? And similar is the condition of all the service sectors?

Let the business house realize that one of its major responsibilities is not only to making profit and increasing its own wealth but also to make the people around them educated, skilled and wealthy.

If the business houses don’t take up this responsibility and change its mindset, I see a bleak future for the country. There can be only one way that will force the change happen. And that will be what is happening in Arab world, but that will not be against only the government but also against all those who could have avoided it to happen.
——-
PS: With 2% of profit for CSR getting mandatory for the Indian Inc., will the corporate take the mission of educating and skilling India 100% in next five years? Premji has already shown the way. Let others join him.

Posted in economy, industry, management | Leave a comment

Politics with Dinkar

The name of the ‘rashtra kavi’ (national poet) Dinkar has appeared in media and this time not for any posthumous award or celebration of any anniversary. It relates a complaint or grievance by Dinkar’s 80-year-old daughter-in-law Hemant Devi and grandson Arvind Kumar Singh against Sushil Modi’s nephew for forcibly occupying a part of the late poet’s house, Dinkar Bhavan, on Arya Kumar Road near Machuatoli in Patna.

Few years ago I was in Patna and staying with Janardan, my relative and friend of Kankarbag As usual in morning walk I had gone up to the house. When I asked someone about Dinkar’s house, a person indicated his finger towards an unassuming house. I had expected it to be a property under some institution or government as well maintained and well preserved museum of Dinkar’s literary manuscripts and belongings. Instead when I thought of entering its open door I got scared thinking someone may charge for trespassing his in his personal property. I just couldn’t go in that. Why do we treat our writers so shabbily? I have seen the fate of Premchand house in Lamhi on TV sometimes. That also gives the same impression. Why are the Hindi states so poor in respecting their great sons whom even the whole world respects? Why can’t the state or some rich men from the state take the task of building a memorial grad enough to match the personality of the poet and author of great literary creations such as Urvashi, Rashmirathi, Parashuram ki Pratiksha, Kurukshetra and Snaskriti ke Char Adhyaya?

I remember how Dinkar made a speech on Marina Beach when JP Narayana was ill. “O God! Please take me away and give JP a longer life.” Interestingly JP survived but Dinkar fell ill and died.

I did also read an article written by Harridans Rai Bachchan on Ramdhari Singh Dinkar in Dharmyug of Dharamvir Bharati era. While talking about his achievements of his life, Dinkar had told the senior Bachchan, “I married sixteen girls of the family. After I got Rs 1 lakh award of Bhartiya Gyan Peeth, the boys’ fathers started saying that now Dinkar is lakhpati so they can expect good dowry.”

Recently, I wrote in my facebook that the credit of Rahman’s ‘Jai Ho’ was first time used in Rashmirathi. Those are the first two words of the famous book. Dinkar’s forceful negation of caste system in Rashimirathi is something to be noted and respected.
‘जय हो’ जग में जले जहाँ भी, नमन पुनीत अनल को,
जिस नर में भी बसे, हमारा नमन तेज को, बल को।
‘क्षत्रिय है, यह राजपुत्र है, यों ही नहीं लड़ेगा,
जिस-तिस से हाथापाई में कैसे कूद पड़ेगा?
अर्जुन से लड़ना हो तो मत गहो सभा में मौन,
नाम-धाम कुछ कहो, बताओ कि तुम जाति हो कौन?’

‘जाति! हाय री जाति !’ कर्ण का हृदय क्षोभ से डोला,
कुपित सूर्य की ओर देख वह वीर क्रोध से बोला
‘जाति-जाति रटते, जिनकी पूँजी केवल पाषंड,
मैं क्या जानूँ जाति ? जाति हैं ये मेरे भुजदंड।

Can’t Bihar government, some other interested agency, an institution or individual acquire the house from the family if it has gone poor enough to maintain its glory at proper price and convert it in a memorial befitting to the name of Dinkar?

Posted in bihar, social issues | Leave a comment

Can there be an Egypt in India any day?

When a national weekly such as ‘India Today’ with so huge a circulation in many local languages beside English publishes someone on its cover page, it must be a serious story getting noticed by almost all in the administrative setup of Indian Government who matter. February 7 issue of ‘India Today’ has a photograph of, Hassan Ali Khan smartly smoking a cigarette and a mind blowing revelation: ‘This man owes Rs 50,000 cr. in taxes. He has $8 billion in a Swiss bank. Why is Government afraid to act?’

And when I was going through Times of India of January31, I found the action of the government through another headline though in an inside page: ‘Hasan Ali’s $6 billion in Swiss a/cs missing’. And the information is credited to the finance Minister.

Interestingly, one another cover page story in ‘India Today’ week ago dealt with the same subject of black money as $500 billion loot: “At least $500 billion, or Rs 22.5 lakh crore, has been spirited out of India illegally to foreign bank accounts over the six decades since Independence. This is the key finding of a comprehensive study on the Drivers and Dynamics of Illicit Financial Flows from India: 1948-2008 conducted by the US-based Global Financial Integrity (GFI).”

How can a citizen know what is truth or what is the intention of the government? Should we overlook media reports?

I get reminded of another story about Quattrocchi. In December 2005: ‘Mr B. Datta, the additional solicitor general of India, acting on behalf of the Indian Government and the CBI, requested the British Government that two British bank accounts of Ottavio Quattrocchi be de-frozen on the grounds of insufficient evidence to link these accounts to the Bofors payoff.’

Interestingly, the principal opposition party has circulated a report on black money after a press conference. How serious are they? Have they taken effective steps in the states they rule?

Should the people keep on watching these news reports on TV channels and reading in newspapers and magazines or react in some effective manner? And how should one react?

Sometimes now I start worrying now. Can one day the people of the country will be forced to behave as Egyptians are doing today even though the persons like me may not wish that to happen?

Posted in governance, indian politics | Leave a comment

Inflation and Exotic Broccoli


The country is worried of the price rise. Harendra had asked for only a small eggplant or baigan. I saw that green vegetable, broccoli that I loved and hated. I went ahead without picking one up though it was lush green indicating it freshness.

I loved it as I liked it and hated as it was vegetable beyond reach. But when I was coming out of the store, I saw by chance a poster hanging in that Safal’s outlet. ‘Exotic Broccoli Rs 25 a kg’. I got surprised. I returned back and reconfirmed. Some persons volunteered information. “The farmers have got the bumper crop. It’s selling Rs 10-15 with vendors on road.”

I used to see only few broccolis with one or two vendors in weekly bazaar on Sunday in front of my house in Noida. Price would be Rs 60-90 per kg. Is it not interesting providing the answer for Manmohan Singh or Pranab babu, if not for Sharad Pawar who hardly bothers about anything but sugarcanes that has sweetened his life till date.

Let the ministers realize the potential of mother earth and the hardworking farmers. Encourage the growers. Pay the right price. All inflation will vanish in air. The case of broccoli can be repeated for anything, be it onion or milk.

India can produce five times of what it produces today. Why should not the government focus on providing the inputs instead of putting all its brainpower in discovering or minting excuses for the inflation and price rise that go in a cycle; sometimes it will be onion, sometimes pulses and sometimes oil.

I only fear the poor farmers must be morose with the crash of the price of broccoli. They will hardly get any return. They would never have thought of getting this poor a price. I am sure they will not grow it next time.

For information, the price of brinjal or baigan was Rs 40 a kg.

It is unfortunate that we don’t get Indian apples and pears any more. Even if you find some, the price will be around Rupees hundred a kg or more. But imported apples, pears and many other fruits are today easily available though at high prices. But the quality appears to be so good that one gets tempted to buy it compromising with quantity. Perhaps, the imported fruits have increased the prices of the local stuffs too.

Is this the price of globalization and free trade?
——-
PS Price of broccoli still remains Rs 25 per kg even on January 31, 2011

Posted in agriculture, economy | Leave a comment

On This Republic Day: Some Observations

After some years, I watched today’s Republic Day parade from start to finish. It really excited me and gave me confidence about India’s great future. At end of the Republic Day Parade, I could conclude to two views about India’s strength.

India has a huge lot and varied soft power that it has hardly tapped to its potential. Each tableau, be it of DRDO, CSIR or cultural ones confirmed my confidence in the view.

I remember an intellectual once saying that ‘one Indian is better than any individual from the developed country but a group of five Indians working together is worse than the worst of such a group from the advanced countries’. And the parade should remove all the doubts about the group working of Indians. Can anyone after seeing the daredevil performance of the motorcyclists question about the ability of Indians for performing the best in group?

But soon after the parade I listened to the news. And two news items not only shocked me but made me feel miserable. How can the country tolerate mafia burning alive an additional collector on duty? Why does a young man attack Rajesh Talwar? Was it just the madness or loss of faith in judiciary or investing agencies? Can the agencies be satisfied after booking for the attempt of murder or look into it a little more seriously?

And a question haunts me. How can persons like Manmohan Singh and Pranab Mukherji from whom the country men expected a lot take an excuse or use their all skills in not divulging the name of those Indians who had stashed unaccounted money abroad in foreign banks?

How long they go on be blind and deaf when ‘a current study by Global Financial Integrity had estimated the present value of illicit money outflow to be $462 billion’?

Why can’t the intellectuals, economists and legal luminaries of the country force them to do that? Why can’t media leak those names as it did the conversation of Nadia?

But then I again want to return for an appeal to the millions of youth of the country to focus on knowledge, innovations and entrepreneurship. How can one deny the huge potential today for the young India working or getting ready to enter in IT, telecom, pharma or auto components sector to innovate new applications, products, and services that can reach far and near and make India great?

Why can’t the politicians, babus and judiciary contribute its best to the growth story by changing the old way of working when they very much know that India can find its place even in spite of that?

——————
PS:I now find many had these questions in mind. Rajdeep Sardesai writes in Hindustan Times, ‘Constitutional crisis’

Posted in economy, social issues | Leave a comment