Education in Rural Region: Some Additional Thoughts

In many of the rural schools such as the one in the photograph in my earlier entry, there is plenty of land to be converted into playground or to develop a good enough nursery to improve the ambiance to make the students learn better. Unfortunately, the school hardly gets a motivated school administrator or headmaster who takes initiative. In good old days, some were easily available as there were missionary educationists at heart inspired by great political leaders such as Mahatma who has social issues as his priority.

English can’t be the right medium till the student understands it as proficiently as his own mother tongues. Unfortunately, in India, many a times, the mother tongues are different than the language used as medium. In Hindi belt itself, the mother tongue is different. Students find it difficult to pick up the matter taught even in Hindi. With Bhojpuri at home and Hindi as medium of instruction, the students find it difficult to grasp the subject taught in Hindi. The school must focus to teach the language of its medium of instruction in the first five years for effective understanding of what is taught. It’s unfortunate that the students even after 10 years of schooling don’t become proficient in the language used as medium, say, Hindi or as second language, such as English. It is only because of the scarcity of good trained teacher. Only the use of technologies both at school by teachers and at home by tutors or guardians can overcome the problem. India had this problem since ages and so is its illiteracy so high. India must learn some lessons from the developed non-English speaking countries. India has wasted 60 years and has still failed in reaching at the right policy on the medium of instruction.

For the students in rural school, the English has been the toughest subject to pass the tests and the reason of shunning the schooling. Interestingly, with emphasis on English they do neither become proficient in Hindi nor in English. Still in hope of better employability in present situation, the English medium schools are mushrooming all over the country, even in rural region.
All the political parties and administrators must agree that the system of temporary or contractual teachers for cutting the cost of educating is not the answer for enhancing the accessibility of education for a larger population. It has made the mess of teaching; Let all the teachers be on regular agreed or better scale to attract the best stuff in teaching. One can’t expect good teaching from third class input of teachers. It’s not only the qualification judged by the certificates and degrees but the aptitude for teaching should be the criteria to select teachers for the rural schools. If anything it is the technology that can facilitate the accessibility of education for all. But it requires a change in the mindsets of those in education sector and setting up of the facilities. Alumni of the schools and the local donors can participate in big way to overcome the financial constraints.

It must be mandatory for the school to impart some skills before a student completes the class x or xii or before he leaves the school even midway.

In good old days, someone in the village used to donate the land and or get constructed the building. The first high school at Samahuta, a village near my own village came up because of the endeavour of one Late Dharamraj Rai. The only girls’ high school there was the work of another person named Raja Rai. The story of BHU that was the handiwork of Madan Mohan Malviya is well known. The education policy for the rural India must emphasize and encourage the role of the locals without which education will not reach to every child of every household.

The school premises must become a place of pride for the community and must come up as a place of worship that provides knowledge as well peace of mind.

Even after the passage of the Right of Education Bill, I doubt the education to spread the way it is intended if the community doesn’t participate positively for educating its children rightly.

I wish the education at rural schools is under an independent group selected by the parents of students and out of the manipulation of the heads of panchayat system that has gone political and so extremely corrupt. People of the community that the school serves, are not bold and conscious enough to stand against the malpractices that the panchayat heads in collusion with the government officers are inflicting on schools and education.

I wish the people are alive to this major issue of building the future generation and find the effective solution to attain 100% literate, enlightened and empowered community through good education from the rural schools.

Posted in education, rural india | Leave a comment

IIT Day Again

And the day would have been one of celebration in thousands of families in India. The result of the entrance examination for IITs has appeared on the website. IIT-JEE over years has become a symbol of the excellence of education in India. It is the most sought after aspiration for the parents for their children- both male and female.

A total of 13,104 out of about 4.5 lakh candidates succeeded this year for entering 15 IITs. It has been increasing every year. The states left out till date, hanker for getting an IIT and / or IIM. I still wonder why the government went on increasing IITs started with the first IIT, Kharagpur instead of bringing these institutes in different names.

Unlike our IIT days with girls almost missing in the campus, engineering education has very much become the domain for the girl-students too.1.13 lakh girls appeared this year in the test, and 1476 are in the list of successful ones.

But more surprising for me is the news of the results for the candidates opting for Hindi in examination because of certain controversies. About 554 candidates in Hindi medium have qualified- a threefold rise over last year’s 184. Anand Kumar of Super 30 along with Nitish Kumar was the most vocal protesters. I am sure there have now no reason to grumble. As promised, IIT authority managed it well. But will not those candidates improve their proficiency of English before it’s too late for a better career?

Legendary ‘Super 30‘ Patna, the unique and free coaching institute for underprivileged and poorest of poor has made it again with 100% success rate. I heard Anand Kumar who announced to increase the number of candidates from 30 to 60 for the next year and upgrade it to Super 60. If I am not mistaken, a similar plan was in media last year too. I wish Anand Kumar would have focused on scaling up the intake of underprivileged children that are in plenty in his own state.

Perhaps all those who talk of and demand for affirmative action must make Super 30 Model as the benchmark. I wish Anand Kumar a success in scaling up the number. If he can do that in Bihar, other states must encourage more Anand Kumars to come up and help affirmative action.

Hundreds of brilliant teachers in every state must take the clue from Anand Kumar or find better means to help the needy students.

However, I still remember the year1957, the registered letter from IIT, Kharagpur that was the gate pass for my entry into the only institute of national importance at that time, travelled from Kharagpur to Birlapur and then redirected to Pipra and my grandfather who accompanied me to Kharagpur to attend the important interview though I was late according to the letter’s date.

There was no web or even telephones for communication.

Posted in education | Tagged | Leave a comment

Troubling Tuesday

I don’t know why but somehow I am getting scared of Tuesday. I have started avoiding expecting any good things to happen on this day.

Believe it, I regularly read ‘Sundar Kand’ of Tulsidas Ramcharitmanas on this day and Saturday to please God Hanuman who eliminates all obstacles.

Alok, my cousin had volunteered to get all the remaining household items out of AJIRA, my abode till recently in Salt Lake City. He was reaching Kolkata from Pipra to help me in closing a deal. I kept on following him. But at the last moment the officers of my tenant refused to oblige me in handing over the possession of my premises to Alok whom I had deputed for the task. They kept me guessing and confused till late in the day. All my persuasions didn’t help. Now it will be done on May 31, the official final day of the tenant.

And in Noida, my RO water filter has failed working since yesterday. In this month itself I had spent Rs 500 on it. I contacted both the repair men who had been doing it. They kept on affirming the visit but didn’t appear. I don’t know why they behave in this manner, when both had charged a lot of money each time they visit. I had to buy a 20-litre bottle of mineral water.

And in the afternoon on this hot summer temperature going up to 50 Celsius, the inverter also got inoperative. Shri Sunil Kumar, a Keralite entrepreneur in Noida and the manufacturer had got it repaired in this month itself. I talked to him and put my cell phone near it to make Kumar hear the type of noise it was making. His service men are not available to repair it: One has gone to Vaishno Devi and the second one is attending in a distant place from where he can’t come tonight. I will have to get fried if there is a power cut tonight.

And my Airtel telephone has gone dead. Anand couldn’t talk to me when he tried. He had to call me on cell phone. But I cut it short as it costs even for incoming call for foreign calls.

I don’t know what is in store. Alok is on way to Pipra on the truck. I am to track him. I pray he reaches home safely.

Should I be superstitious or take it in stride?

Posted in personal | Leave a comment

Education in Rural Region

While the wide media coverage of the battle between Nitish vs. Narendra was the cause of morose for many, I had some reason to keep my hope of developmental politics alive. I kept on hearing about Nitish Kumar visiting schools during his Viswas Yatra and his dialogue with the students and teachers. His blog on the positive effect of state gifted bicycles for students on improving enrolment and reduction in the figures of dropouts kept me and perhaps many pretty excited.

Deepak and Prakash visited me on their return journey after a ten-day off in Pipra, their village home and stayed with us for a night with their mother. Both are pursuing master course in engineering, the elder in BITS, Pilani and the younger in IIIT, Bhuwaneswar.

I wish to do something to improve the quality of education in the village school and have a plan to set up a library cum creativity centre in the school. I am ready to bear all the expenditures of books and implements. I had discussed the same with some coming out of the village who are employed. And then, I talked about the same project with my uncle. He had been library enthusiast in his early days. I was surprised when he in plain language discouraged me to do anything of the sort. As per him, it is not of any use rather it will be a waste of money.

Deepak and Prakash, his grandsons also brought his message.

The village school runs classes up to class VIII and may add up to class X by next year. I considered it as a major achievement for the village. But I find few things that must be taken care of.

School: The school consists of just few rooms. There is a boundary wall but no gate that can be locked. It has no security guard for protecting the school in the night or when it’s not running. The condition is same for all the schools that I know all around my village. Many don’t have even boundary wall. I don’t know why the Panchayat or the government can’t engage and employ a full time guard and a residence for him in one corner in the premises. He could be engaged in multiple roles for different essential work in the school such as housekeeping and cleaning too.

Without the necessary arrangement against the burglary, one can’t even dream of a modern good school with many essential equipment and teaching aids such as audio and video system, computers and internet facilities and other facilities in its laboratories. The government must think on this aspect as an essential requirement if it has intention to make the school taking the advantages of the contemporary technologies.

Teachers: Most of the teachers are very lowly paid as ‘Shiksha Mitra’ and are hardly devoted to their work of teaching. Many are not even qualified and skilled enough to do that. I don’t know why the government resorted to such a system to save the cost of education. It has just created a band of discontented teachers in a government set up that is already not ready to be accountable for the performance.

Community: I don’t know how the present system of education can impart and ensure quality learning to the students and who will do that, if the community is not ready to take any interest and leaves everything to the so called government to do. Every school requires a mentor to see that it functions effectively. A good mentor can only build a good school. I wish the community being served by the school does find one.

I don’t know if the schools in the other states are significantly different.

If I go by what I hear from my uncle who had been instrumental in bringing many developments to the village and others who have served in responsible positions such as senior teachers and headmasters of high schools, I get worried and lose hope.
The finance is not a problem in providing and spreading the education to all today. It is the atmosphere of brotherhood and fellowship that is getting scarce.

I wish Nitish Kumar and other leaders, through the mass contact such as Vishwas Yatra, discuss this subject too. Perhaps, for the first time a Chief Minister is visiting schools and that too, the rural ones on such a scale to find out firsthand the conditions and shortcomings of the schooling in the state. It’s a great gesture and it is bound to encourage the students as well as their parents for focusing on education to bring in better days in their households. Let it not be only for votes. Let it build a society with better fellowship in the communities and make it responsible and accountable for the government projects taken up to benefit them.

I wish him also to appeal the students and teachers to switch over to the modern education system with English, computer, and skill as the main focus to compete with other developed states.

I wish Nitish appeals to the villagers to nurture and build the village-school as a place of pride for the village, with a library and creativity centre, a play ground for all the village youth and a meeting place for all to further their knowledge through schemes such as adult education.

Posted in education, rural india | Leave a comment

Ratan Tata – A CEO with Difference

First I thought of calling Ratan Tata a business leader, but then decided for CEO. Many of my era doubted Ratan Tata to be the right man to succeed a stalwart like JRD Tata. But today I consider him as pre-Duryodhana Bhishma of Tata Empire. Ratan Tata, the head of Tata Group is also the chairman of Indian Hotels owning the Taj Mahal Hotel Mumbai, one of the targets of the terrorists of 26/11.

One of the entries in my friend, OP Khanna’s regular mails was on the gestures of Tata after 26/11 and I thought it to share with my readers. Here is the listing of what Ratan and his men did:

All category of employees including those who had completed even 1 day as casuals were treated on duty during the time the hotel was closed.

Relief and assistance was provided not only to all those who were injured and killed but extended to all those who died at and around the railway station including the “Pav- Bha ji” vendor and the pan shop owners.

During the time the hotel was closed, the salaries were sent by money order.

A psychiatric cell was established in collaboration with Tata Institute of Social Sciences to counsel those who needed such help.

Employee outreach centers were opened where all help, food, water, sanitation, first aid and counseling was provided. 1600 employees were covered by this facility.

Every employee was assigned to one mentor and it was that person’s responsibility to act as a “single window” clearance for any help that the person required.

Ratan Tata personally visited the families of all the 80 employees who in some manner – either through injury or getting killed – were affected.

The dependents of the employees were flown from outside Mumbai to Mumbai and taken care off in terms of ensuring mental assurance and peace. They were all accommodated in Hotel President for 3 weeks.

Ratan Tata himself asked the families and dependents – as to what they wanted him to do.

In a record time of 20 days, a new trust was created by the Tatas for the purpose of relief of employees.

Even other people, the railway employees, the police staff, the pedestrians who had nothing to do with Tatas were covered by compensation. Each one of them received subsistence allowance of Rs. 10K per month for 6 months.

A 4 year old granddaughter of a vendor got 4 bullets in her and only one was removed in the Government hospital. She was taken to Bombay hospital and several lakhs were spent by the Tatas on her to fully recover her.

New hand carts were provided to several vendors who lost their carts.

Tata will take took responsibility of education of 46 children of the victims of the terror.

Senior managers including Ratan Tata were visiting funeral to funeral over the 3 days that were most horrible.

The settlement for every deceased member ranged from Rs. 36 to 85 lakhs [One lakh rupees are about approx 2200 US $] in addition to the following benefits:

a. Full last salary for life for the family and dependents;
b. Complete responsibility of education of children and dependents – anywhere in the world.
c. Full Medical facility for the whole family and dependents for rest of their life.
d. All loans and advances were waived off – irrespective of the amount.
e. Counselor for life for each person

It has to do with the DNA of the organization, with the way Tata culture exists and above all with the situation that prevailed that time. The organization has always been telling that customers and guests are #1 priority

The hotel business was started by Jamshedji Tata when he was insulted in one of the British hotels and not allowed to stay there. He created several institutions which later became icons of progress, culture and modernity. IISc is one such institute. He was told by the rulers that time that he can acquire land for IISc to the extent he could fence the same. He could afford fencing only 400 acres.

When the HR function hesitatingly made a very rich proposal to Ratan – he said – do you think we are doing enough?

The whole approach was that the organization would spend several hundred crore in re-building the property – why not spend equally on the employees who gave their life.

Should not Ratan be considered as the best face of Indian management?

Posted in industry, management | Leave a comment

Food Grains Shortage: A Myth or Mismanagement

India’s fourth good harvest in a row has swelled wheat stocks to 31 million tonnes, almost eight times its target of 4 million, forcing authorities to pile up nearly 7 million tonnes of grain under tarpaulin in the grainbowl states of Punjab and Haryana.

Stocks of rice, too, at 26 million tonnes, are more than double the target of 12.2 million and set to soar as forecasts of normal monsoon rainfall from June will help the crop bounce back from a 14% fall after last year’s drought.

Should the report above excite us?

The country’s inflation rate is still in double digits. Almost all state government find itself helpless in stopping the hunger deaths of the people of the BPL category and destitute. The centre takes a course of shifting the responsibility to the state governments.

Are not the food shortages in the country only its mismanagement? Why can’t the basic priciples of inventory management such as FIFO be applied?

Let the government or FCI announce a policy to outsource the task of storage to the private enterprises. There will be hundreds and thousands of takers of the business.

While the grains in millions of tones are kept in open to get spoiled, a large number of abandoned warehouses and factory sheds and other buildings in almost every part of the country remain unutilized. The right hand doesn’t know what is there in left hand.

Why should not the scientists and entrepreneurs innovate and manufacture better bags that can keep the grains in it safe and protected from rain?

Is it not criminal to waste and spoil grains when millions of hungry people are going to sleep without food?

Should not the UPA-II government reviewing its performance of the first year in power in its second inning consider the situation as one of its biggest failure?

Posted in agriculture, governance | Leave a comment

Can India Inc Educate Deprived India?

I go back to my school days in Birlapur. Our school, Birlapur Vidyalaya, was in the factory campus and Birla Jute Manufacturing Company (presently known as Birla Corporation) financed it. The company had a scheme for the educating the children of factory employees. Two of my own uncles went for education in Birla’s educational establishment in Pilani. Unfortunately, they couldn’t continue because of the fault of their own. But many availed it fully. Manorama Shrivastava (Pandey), the eldest daughter of my assistant headmaster and her uncle, Rajendra Sharma, son of an employee in mill, Jharkhandey Singh, the younger brother of another teacher, and many availed the facility and continued up to master level. It was a totally free education including even pocket money and clothing. I am sure there might be many other companies doing that.

I am not sure if the scheme exists any more. Perhaps the decline of the group or the cost cutting exercises caused the death of the scheme. But I am sure if the group could afford that in 50s, many other industrial houses and professional companies could do that even now with the advantages coming after liberalization in industrial policies and death of license raj. If I am to believe the balance sheets, websites, and media reports, most of the big companies in India are involved in the education and other tasks in name of corporate social responsibility, but it’s not focused and the impacts are not visible.

Today Indian corporate in large number must get into the philanthropic task of educating the deprived India to help effectively in the inclusive growth that the country badly needs. It will be more efficient in managing the institutes and ensuring the quality education and learning for the students as against the same by government schools. The prime minister and the education minister can take the initiative to bring the industry, both private as well as public, in the fold to help the country becoming a knowledge power.

Think of at least 100 (number can be much bigger) Indian big industrial corporations setting up and promoting a large education city each to impart education of all levels to the children of the deprived classes and the impact it will make. The city can have a university with number of engineering and medical institutes, science colleges, along with a larger number of schools that will provide the input for the colleges. And the education city can also have facility for large scale skill building too. It will also improve the employability of the graduates with the input from the companies who ultimately engage them. Will not the education from a university set up by Infosys, TCS, or Wipro be better oriented for IT sector? Tata, L&T, M&M, or for that matter Reliance Group can certainly create an educational institute that can be something like MIT of India. Unfortunately, the big brands of Indian industry have not, very lately shown interest in setting up educational and research institutes that can become globally known as pioneer its fields.

I get excited with the news emanating from the rural development ministry. As reported, nearly 100 companies had responded positively to a notice issued last month inviting “expressions of interest” for implementing the Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas (PURA) scheme under a public-private partnership (PPP) framework. I am sure it will include education centres coming up in rural India. Fortunately, companies like Tata Power, Tata Realty & Infrastructure, Jindal Steels & Power, cement manufacturer ACC and Reliance Energy have sent proposals.

According to another report, the government has decided to allow corporates, non-profit companies and societies to open 2,500 schools across the country. The Public Private Partnership (PPP) model allows the government to fill 1,000 of the 2,500 seats in each school with children from the deprived sections. The scheme must be able to screen out unscrupulous entrepreneurs in education that have come in huge numbers.

I wish the corporates with a mission for the inclusive growth must take on the responsibility of the quality education of the deprived class, both in rural as well as urban regions, otherwise the country can’t think of having its largest youth population as advantage over the aging countries. This can be the only way to bring the death of the poverty and the menace of Maoism. Can’t CII take up the task?

Posted in education, industry | Leave a comment

Ganga: From Mother to Untouchable Status

Ganga must be cursing Bhagirathi to bring her down to earth@. And the most to be blamed are the Hindus who call her Mother Ganga. Each one starts polluting it from birth and in death too.

And I feel like blaming Vishnu who made Garga descend on earth giving a divine power to her water to absolve all the sins.

Does not every Hindu put all his sins and filths that he generates including his ashes after death and even the carcasses of his pets in the water of Ganga for getting easy salvation?

Where is Vishnu and where is his Chakra? Why is He not getting incarnated again to save Her?

I wish and wonder if all the religious leaders come out with a fatwa to save Ganga that has become a national necessity today. What will be the values of the temples in Varanasi or elsewhere if the rivers become a sewerage drain or die?

Why do BJP and VHP still talk of building the Ram temple? If the party wishes to unite the Indians of all hues, it must put all its resources and propaganda machinery to save the River Ganga.

Shadus and intellectuals must come out to do everything to save it. All the industrialists must take vow to stop draining their pollutants of their enterprises that cause the maximum damage. And let them remember if they don’t do that all their charities and donations to Balaji and other Gods will not save them from the curse of Mother river to get a hell for hundreds of lives to come.

The government that proclaims itself secular has failed to clean the rivers. Can the people of the country do that?

Can we ponder over our actions as Hindu to save Ganga? Can we ask our heirs not to immerse the ashes after our death for our salvation? I refuse to go to Heaven, even if there is any and even if it’s true, if it contributes to the death of mother river. —————————
@”The myth goes that when King Bhagirath asked Ganga to come down to earth, she put her foot down and said no. Then Vishnu intervened. He promised that all the sins accumulated by mortals would dissolve the moment sages entered her waters for ablutions. Finally, Ganga relented.”

Posted in governance, social issues | Leave a comment

Hurdles of Higher Education

India may soon attract a lot of good foreign universities to set up its shop. And if it happens, naturally that may force IITs and other top technical institutes to compete with the best of the world.

But naturally a question crops up in mind. Will the foreign universities come with the same quality level of education or will it dilute its standard for India for the prices that it may fetch for its education? I am sure the present semester charges of many of the top class American universities as charged in US dollars will be too high for the Indian parents. Though many banks are providing easy education loans, the Indian parents still like to bear that expenditure, as they don’t wish to burden their children at that age.

Will the foreign universities use the localization as route for cutting down their cost? Naturally, they can poach on local teachers, train them and use them to cut the cost of teaching. After all, as reported, the teachers in the institutes of national importance are pretty lowly paid. “Saudi Arabia paid its professors the highest on an average – $6,611, followed by Canada at $6,548 and United States at $5,816 per month. India pays only – $1,547”. They can use the teaching materials from the faculty of the parent institute either digitally or through local printing.

Will the local teachers come up to the efficiency level of those in the best of the foreign universities?

I don’t know if they commit to set up the research laboratories, but they may decide in favour of doing that taking a clue from all the MNCs that have set up R&D centres in India. And who knows after some time they may bring the American students to work in the Indian laboratories.

In fact, according the University Grants Commission’s data, there are 156 foreign providers, including 90 universities and 20 colleges, who have collaboration with Indian institutions.

Some universities have been already trying to enter India. As reported, Georgia Tech and the Schulich School of Business already tied up with some Indian investors and bought huge tracts of land in Mumbai and Hyderabad respectively, when the real estate market was in the slump.

But main thrust must be on the quantity and more so the quality of secondary and higher secondary education that will decide the quality of the input to the higher education. It primarily means quality and dedicated teachers and facilities, particularly in government schools that provide the major portion of the output for the higher education.

Many things are happening and fast too in education sector. Many reforms are on anvil. Enrollment in primary level has seen tremendous rise. Sarv Sikhsha Aviyan is now ready to cover secondary education too.

Will India see that light in education sector that can make it the leader in the world? I wish the corporate India would have participated and invested in the task in big way as it did in setting up of some of the best educational institutes in the past.

Posted in education | Leave a comment

A Bad Sad Sunday: Meeting Eternity

An early morning unexpected telephone from Beena Lakshman Singh on cell gave the sad news. I had not taken the call myself as perhaps somehow I could sense the bad news. The cell was in bed room and we were in the lobby. I had just returned from my morning walk and Yamuna had joined me. I rushed, picked up the cell, after seeing the caller, horridly walked back and handed over to Yamuna.

Lakshman Singh passed away on May 6 itself. We had talked in between with Beena but she didn’t reveal the news, perhaps to save us from the mental agony that the news would have given. She with Burmans (Dr. Burman and his sons) and some close relative from Lucknow carried out all the rites. Rajat couldn’t be called, as he was in Spain for an interview. Beena bhabhi came to Lucknow for the religious ceremonies.

It was perhaps only after completing all the tasks and returning to Kolkata, Beena bhabhi called us.

Hat off to Beena, the brave lady who faced the whole problems at this advanced age herself! It is really difficult to appreciate this.

Lakshman Singh worked for me in Hindustan Motors. He must be around 80.

Let his soul rest in peace and God gives Beena all the strength to face the life after him. She has another duty- a handicapped son who is still with her. I wish Rajat or some kind soul helps Beena in finding a good place for him where he can be cared for the rest of his life.

Beena bhabhi! You are great, but I never thought you to be so brave and tough to conceal the news for so many days when we were almost everyday talking.

Show equal toughness to live the rest of life. Let God give the agility to face the situation. We all are with you.

Posted in personal | Leave a comment